They have both bigger canines and smaller needle-like teeth. your own Pins on Pinterest I generally fish in Little Saint Germain Lake in Northern Wisconsin. Both species have forked tails, but Muskie have much more pointed forks, while Pike tails are more rounded. However, Muskie do grow to be much bigger than Pike. Beautiful green colors and design!ââ No sirâ¦ Thatâs most likely a chain pickerel. White and flakey and virtually no fishy taste. vary state by state. Even so, there are a few go-to tactics for both species. A muskie 55 inches long was caught by an angler on Island Lake last year. Musky are much more limited in their range, although both fish like the same kind of habitat and hunt in a similar way. I should say that I caught a bunch of Pike with a MEPS #3 this summer (Dyrberry Lake, Ontario). She is our Baitshop.com Beauty of the Month for September. Started fishing randomly with very little experience. The danger to the Muskie population in the lake occurs in the first few months of life when they are smaller than the young Pike. 3) Seasons, limits etc. Fishing in Portugal – All You Need to Know, Fishing in San Antonio – Your Complete Guide. Count the pores. Northern Pike and Muskellunge are close relatives. Live bait also works, as long as it’s the right size to attract their attention. The Bigger your fly is, the greater the â¦ Their outlandish looks, large size, and rarity put them high on many anglers’ bucket lists. Good luck on the Muskie hunt. The lure that I used was red & white Abu Garcia HiLo, if I remember correctly. Biker. St. Croix River. Good luck on the Muskie hunt – I guess they call them “the fish of a thousand casts” for a reason! Jonsey. The muskellunge (Esox masquinongy), often shortened to muskie, musky or lunge, is a species of large freshwater fish native to North America. Muskie vs. Pike A lot of anglers new to muskie and pike fishing have a hard time telling the difference between these two fish. They’re very rare in the wild, but they are stocked in some waters. In this article, you can delve into the world of âMuskie vs. Pike.â Learn how to tell the two fish apart and where you should go to find them. Muskie have a much more limited distribution. Take a look at the scales on their face. Generally slow ponds with shallow water are great. In lakes where both northern pike and muskies live, muskies spawn after the northerns. Even small Pike can put you through your paces, so I bet you had a lot of fun with that 26 pounder. Aim for a âfollowâ (the sight of a fish chasing your lure) and you might be rewarded with a hookup. A pond management bulletin from Michigan State University Extension does not recommend stocking northern pike or muskellunge in ponds. They are the best fish I’ve ever eaten. Best fight!!! If all else fails, there’s one surefire way to know what fish you’re holding: Turn it over and look at the underside of the jaw. Such an amazing fish! A pike would be on it very quickly and they were huge…. Replied on September 2, 2020 Muskie Vs Pike. Pike are less fussy about where they live. In this article, you can delve into the world of “Muskie vs. Pike.” Learn how to tell the two fish apart and where you should go to find them. Down south now and I miss “northerns’ quite a bit…, Replied on October 23, 2020 The best lures for catching Musky are large jigs, jerkbaits, diving plugs, and bucktail spinners. The muskie vs. walleye war has flared up at Capitol with a bill that would halt muskellunge stocking and even open spearing on some waters. I caught a muskie on a popper. Your Muskie habitat distribution is way off. Musky are a more prestigious catch because they’re so unpredictable, but Pike definitely deserve legendary status, too. You can commonly catch a Pike â¦ Color and size aren’t always reliable, as Muskie vary a lot in both. It’s always best to start at the beginning. Muskellunge (Muskie) Information, Photos, and Facts. Muskie and Pike are both long, pointy, freshwater fish. You can sign in to vote the answer. Caught a rare tiger muskie on Caldron Falls Reservoir in Wisconsin a few years ago. Please indulge a couple of out of state questions. 1) Do Pike or Muskie taste good? Live bait also works, as long as itâs the right size to attract their attention. Great article! But when we looked at the images afterwards, we were left with a nagging question. You should be able to identify your fish without feeling its face, though. The largest Pike I’v ever catched was around ~26lbs, and man… That was A FIGHT! If you want the best chance of landing a Muskie, stick to the Great Lakes and the rivers around them. Are Tiger Muskie a subspecies of Muskie? That #3 has been my “go to” lure for northern for many years!! That sounds quite a fight – and a big surprise when you realised what you’d hooked! Fishing near that stone bridge in Kingston seems like a dream. Muskie and Pike are often around the same size. Because of this, theyâre prized game fish throughout their range. However, Muskie do grow to be much bigger than Pike. They can show up in smaller rivers and ponds, as well as all the places Muskie tend to inhabit. Telling ... youtube.com Tiger Musky & Northern Pike â¦ muskie vs 10 lb. IDO » Community » Forums » Fishing Forums » Fishing by Species » Muskie & Pike » Muskie VS Pikeâ¦ Cleveland Chapter 23 of Muskie Inc. Replied on August 12, 2020 Musky are much more limited in their range, although both fish like the same kind of habitat and hunt in a similar way. Lv 6. I caught my first Musky just two days ago, a 36-40 inch fighter in the St. Clair River. On Wednesday, a â¦ Muskie can vary a lot in color and pattern. These are both highly predatory fish, built for speed and strength. Pike and Muskie will generally stick to shallow, sluggish water and rarely go below 40 feet deep. Some areas may contain "Silver Pike", which is a mutant color variation of a Northern Pike. Muskie Guy's Lure Profile Archives . All rights reserved. I bet the fight was great. It lives in freshwater and its range extends to Canada, the Northeast, and the Midwest United States. They both have several things in common. Northern Pike and Muskellunge may have very different distributions, but they have similar tastes in habitat. What’s your favorite Pike fishery from your travels? Both species have forked tails but muskies have pointed tails and pike are more rounded. They were also introduced into Lake Manitoba and Lake Winnipeg, but catches in these lakes are very rare. Muskie VS Pike â The Ultimate Showdown Of 2 Large Fish By Muskie Press November 3, 2020 All Things Muskie 0 Comments Table of contents Muskie vs Pike FAQ Muskie Vs Tiger Muskie Vs Pike Differences of Muskie Vs Pike Closing In North America, there are large, predatory freshwater fish species, known as Northern Pike and Muskie (aka muskellungeâ¦ Source(s): https://shrink.im/a0tn8. The Drifter Predator XL Musky Net is one of the toughest â¦ That really depends on the species. Itâs harder to get Musky to bite, but you should always be happy to see either fish on the end of your line. âMuskieâ and âMuskyâ are both accepted spellings and most people use them interchangeably. You can find both fish in all five lakes and the surrounding rivers. "Silver Pike" have similar fin colorartion as a normal Northern Pike. It’s great to hear that you released it unharmed. Whether youâre a die-hard Muskie fan, a proud Pike lover, or a complete beginner, you can always learn more about these majestic creatures. But when we looked at the images afterwards, we were left with a nagging question. How do you think about the answers? How To Choose The Best Fly Rod For Musky Trident Fishing. IDO » Community » Forums » Fishing Forums » Fishing by Species » Muskie & Pike » Muskie VS Pike. Even though they prefer the shallows, Musky also like to keep their options open, so shallow vegetation with easy access to deeper water is always a good place to try. pike maybe an even fight but the 20 lb ski vs. the 20. northern I'd take the ski. However, there are three easy ways to identify the fish on the end of your line. Pike and Muskie both thrive in and around the Great Lakes. I’m glad you managed to release the fish safely, and that it didn’t break off your leader. âThere are hundreds of times more biomass â hundreds of times more â of pike than muskies, even on our densest muskie lakes.â Dave Orrick can be reached at 651-228-5512. I hope this helps! Pike and Muskie are both amazing fish to catch. They’re both ambush hunters that hide among thick vegetation, waiting for a meal to swim their way. The fish had the noticeable markings of both a barred muskie (one of the many colour/pattern phases of E. masquinongy) and a tiger muskieâthe relatively rare, sterile cross that is produced when a muskellunge mates with a northern pike. Theyâre both from the genus âEsoxâ along with other Pikes and Pickerels. Average size is about 7-10 pounds and the further north you head the bigger they get, Replied on August 20, 2020 Even small Pike put up a fight. It's tough for a population to replace that big fish. And keep up-to-date with Canada's fishing and hunting authority! However, there are three easy ways to identify the fish on the end of your line. So how do you know which one youâve caught? As an avid and dedicated Esox Angler, I will continually try to discover/discuss factors directly linked to incidental mortality of muskie and pike â¦ the fish intended to be released effectively. Pike & Muskie both look a little like Barracuda ? 2. However, theyâre not the same or varieties of the same fish. We had lots of pike close to home, so he’d go after muskie – we used alot of Big Doctors, red eyes, and various daredevils. IDO » Community » Forums » Fishing Forums » Fishing by Species » Muskie & Pike » Muskie VS Pike. It is a carnivorous fish. Both these fish are apex predators who use every bit of their strength and agility in the fight. Pike are a classic fly fishing target. Actually, neither. Discover (and save!) Muskie Guy's Lure Profile Archives. Muskie Vs Pike. Identification A muskie is not a freakin pickerel or pikeâ¦ Pike have 4–5 pores on each side, Muskie have 6–9. Aug 18, 2020. Pike will shred thin fishing lines. 3. That is, unless the shallows get too warm or thereâs more food farther down. The scientific name for Muskie is Esox Masquinongy. As I always say, the best lure is the one the locals use. Depending on where you catch them, they may be called Muskellunge, Muskelunge, Muscallonge, Maskinonge, or Milliganong. were they a quality boat company back in the early 90s? Here are the basics on where to find Pike and Muskie. You can follow most of the tips for Pike fishing when going after Musky: Fish the weeds. Check the tail. You can catch Pike in most of North America, From the northwest of Alaska all the way over to Labrador in eastern Canada. Be sure to check back in when you finally land one. Mar 24, 2019 - This Pin was discovered by john carter. Still can’t tell whether you’ve caught a Muskie or a Pike? 0 0. Muskie isnât the same as pike although they look similar. I hope you get to take on a Musky one day, too. Probably casted in the same spot about 30 times before the fish hit. HOW TO TELL MUSKELLUNGE, NORTHERN PIKE & PICKEREL APART. In response to a yearslong state effort to expand muskie stocking, a bipartisan group of lawmakers has proposed a sweeping bill that would turn back the clock on recent victories for muskie â¦ Replied on January 29, 2020 It is the largest member of the pike family, Esocidae. The St John River has great Muskie fishing, as do many rivers and streams that aren’t shown here. The natural range of the muskie spans from north to south from Tennessee to mid-Ontario, and from east to west from New York to Minnesota. 1. You can catch Pike in most of North America, From the northwest of Alaska all the way over to Labrador in eastern Canada. Pike are the opposite. Recipe & video: Tender goose with Morocco-inspired spices, Recipe & video: Tuscan walleye blends tastes of central Italy with a Canadian favourite, Blue Fish Radio: What â¦ Have you ever managed to catch a Musky? Actually, neither. Don't like to take them over 30". Use a wire leader if you want to keep your lure. Just make sure you’re using weedless flies if you don’t want to take half the lake away with you. Pike will go for much larger prey in autumn when they’re stocking up for the winter. Grew up fishing for muskie and northerns on St Lawrence (Thousand Islands). Muskie are also famously hard to hook, hence the nickname “fish of a thousand casts.” They’re difficult to trick and impossible to predict. Even so, there are a few go-to tactics for both species. Both fish prefer clear water, probably because they’re sight-based hunters.